Thursday, November 26, 2009

More than Medication Commercial

This commercial uses the logical fallacy hasty generalization. However, it uses it in an interesting way. The commercial uses this fallacy intentionally, to help get their point across. They want the audience to take an inductive leap and use hasty generalization in the beginning of the commercial. They do this by presenting the audience with facts that are presented to make you assume something untrue. The commercial does this with the teenage boy that we see in the beginning of the commercial. They boy looks like a typical troublemaker. He has on baggy jeans, a hat which is worn off to the side, and a baggy sweater as well as various piercings. Also, he is in a dark, deserted alleyway. In addition, he has a spray paint can and he is spray painting the sides of buildings. The creator of the commercial has also added music that contributes to the mood of the commercial because it is a bit spooky and eerie, as if something bad is happening. All of this put together makes the audience think that the boy is vandalising the buildings and that he is a bad kid. Another contributing factor is that the area he is in looks to be run down. It has older building and not much light. It reminds me of an alleyway in a rundown part of New York City. These facts make the audience take an inductive leap and use the logical fallacy hasty generalization, which is exactly what the ad producers want us to do.
After the boy is done spray painting, he is seen entering an apartment building. The apartment building is also run down, with little paint or decoration. It looks fairly drab. This of course is more proof that the boy is up to trouble. When he gets up to his apartment, we see a woman, most likely his mother, looking disappointed. She looks at her watch and gives the boy a look that seems to say “Again? I’m really disappointed in you.” This makes the audience think that this has happened before and that this boy has a history of trouble. The mother in the commercial looks really worn out and tired. We assume it’s because her son was out all night again. The boy gives her a shrug and a defensive look and then proceeds to take a vase of flowers and bring them into a bedroom. At this point the audience is intrigued. We don’t know what he is about to do. The mother in the commercial reflects this emotion. She looks confused. Then, the boy walks into a room where a little girl is lying in a big bed, with tubes running out of her. It is clear that this girl is ill with something serious. The boy then puts the flowers on her bedside table and opens up the curtains. A look of amazement crosses the girl’s face as well as the mother’s. The mother then mouths “thank you” and the boy just humbly nods his head. At this point the audience is hooked. We don’t know what to expect. It seems as though our inductive leap was completely off and now we want to know the truth. We then get a shot of the view outside the little girl’s window. All across the buildings the boys has spray pained flowers and the words “Be Brave” for his little sister.
This commercial is successful for many reasons. First of all, the audience is hooked from almost the very beginning. Right when we see the boy spray painting we think, “what is he doing?” and “how is this going to turn out?” We then think that we know what is happening but we still want to know what the consequence for his actions will be. So we keep watching. Then when we see the mother, we all think that she’s going to get angry or something but she doesn’t, and then when the boy walks into the little girl’s room it is even more intriguing because we are curious as to what’s going to happen and how the little girl works into the plotline. Finally, when we realize that the boy did something good, we are anxious to know what it was. And when we see what he did we are both shocked and touched. This commercial is one that you remember because the commercial producer had you completely fooled. You were at their mercy so totally that when you realize that you had it wrong it shocks you and that shock is something that you remember. Also, when you see the little girl who is so sick, you can’t help but feel compassion. This ad tugs at your heart strings and makes you want to support the cause.
One thing that the ad producer has done to help make the ad effective is the use of lighting. At the beginning of the commercial it is very dark and shady. This is when you think that the boy is up to no good. Then as you get to the apartment, it starts to lighten up a bit and finally, when the boy opens the curtains and you see what he’s done, the last of the light streams in. As the ad progresses and the boy’s intentions become clearer and clearer, you get more and more light. It takes the saying “shed some light on the situation” quite literally. Another thing that the ad producer has used is sound. As mentioned previously, in the beginning of the commercial the music that is played is a bit spooky and eerie. Also, the sound of the spray paint is almost amplified, as if to highlight its use. As the commercial continues, the music gets let eerie and lighter. Then, when the curtains are thrust open, the music seems to soar, almost like there is hope for the little girl, like he is giving her hope through his art. There is no dialogue in the commercial and I think that makes it more powerful because it proves the saying “actions speak louder than words.” One final thing that the producer has done is they have made the mother a reflection of the audience, in a way. The mother is put in the same place as the audience when she sees her son come in the apartment. She thinks he has been up to no good and she is disappointed in him. Then, when he takes the flowers, she is confused, just like the audience. Finally, she is thankful for what he has done, and she is proud. This helps the ad because it helps the audience relate to someone in the ad. If the audience can relate to someone in the ad, then it is more likely to affect us, because it is relevant to our lives. As you can see, this ad uses many different techniques to be effective, including the intentional use of a logical fallacy.

No comments:

Post a Comment